Joined: Sat Jan 16, 2010 2:18 pm Posts: 2257 Location: Niagara Falls
Ent for the second entry cause the OSL is quite sharp. My only qualm is that it is hard to gage if other areas have seen any sort of subtle painting. I get the effect the artist went for but even so, some areas would still look different from another. I.e axe head to the fur.
Joined: Fri May 07, 2010 1:38 pm Posts: 1959 Location: In your closet, folding your fitted sheets
Gotta agree with sonofkritinos. Entry #1 looks unfinished and rushed. Entry #2 is visually striking with that OSL. The monochrome is nice and an awesome way to paint, but some parts would look better with a lighter hue of the brown but overall it is a stunning piece.
_________________ ZOMG IMMA GIRL! Check out Smartah Studios on Facebook! Follow me on Twitter! @Smartah
My Armies: Ogre Kingdoms [X---------] Painted (10%) Eldar [X----------] Painted (4%)
Joined: Tue Jun 21, 2011 4:42 am Posts: 491 Location: Dayton, Ohio USA
Went with #2 as well. The OSL is brilliant and took the show. There are some parts of the model that are lost in the monochromatic scheme, but kudos to the painter as that his very difficult to do at all.
_________________ www.midge913.com Commissions, Works in Progress, and Gallery Follow me on Twitter:@MidgesWorkshop
I did vote for the second one becaus the effect is really cool but that is all that makes it cool, I do beleive that it needs more colour. but props to the first entry
_________________ "If this was Facebook, I would have liked all of Paladins posts so far." -Dez "pally is fairly awes-mazing" -BewareOfTom "paladin zebra is an awesome paladin class zebra warrior" -Sniperfex
Voted for 2. Reason being the top one is far from finished and even in a finished state it would of been out done by that osl. I'd of liked a bit more colour on 2 but on the right scenic base that would of worked a treat.